| 00:00:385 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Thomas P.M. Barnett, what`s "The Pentagon`s New Map"? |
| 00:00:4328 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, what the book tries to do, really, is nothing less than to enunciate a successor to the cold war strategy of containment, in effect, to define... |
| 00:01:1152 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
And the mantra I use in the book is that it`s disconnectedness that defines danger. If you think about globalization as a process of integration, then... |
| 00:02:0322 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
And it`s in that disconnectedness that we tend to find the violence and the bad treatment. And in many ways, what you`re waging war against with a bin... |
| 00:02:2512 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Before we get into some of your theories, I want to go through what`s written about you in the back and just quickly get you to -- the word that we... |
| 00:02:37 |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
OK. |
| 00:02:3714 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
... so that we can an idea of where you`re coming from. Senior strategic researcher and professor at the U.S. Naval War College from October 2001 to... |
| 00:02:5115 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, actually, that goes all the way back to 1998. I had done eight years here in Washington at the Center for Naval Analyses, which is sort of the... |
| 00:03:0625 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
One of the key things I did during that time period was I ran a series of workshops with Cantor Fitzgerald, atop the World Trade Center, where we brought... |
| 00:03:3134 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
That gets wiped off the board with 9/11 because Cantor loses so many people. At that point, the person who had been the president of the Naval War College,... |
| 00:04:0538 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
So Art Zabrowsky calls me soon after 9/11, knowing that my project`s been shot out from under me, somewhat literally, and says, Come work for me. We... |
| 00:04:4324 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
That`s when I start putting together this briefing, which I deliver throughout OSD -- I do it 150 times, roughly, to 4,000 or 5,000 DoD officials --... |
| 00:05:0710 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
And that receives good purchase within this administration. They let me brief it all over. It becomes an "Esquire" article. That becomes a book. That`s... |
| 00:05:175 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
I want to get -- I want to get beyond the -- I want to get beyond the language. OSD stands for? |
| 00:05:221 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Office of the secretary of defense. |
| 00:05:231 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
DoD stands for? |
| 00:05:241 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Department of Defense. |
| 00:05:256 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
If someone were to walk inside the U.S. Naval War College -- first of all, where it is? |
| 00:05:311 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
It`s in Newport, Rhode Island. |
| 00:05:322 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
How many people would be inside it? |
| 00:05:3419 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
You`re going to see a staff of 200 or 300. They`re going to process officers, graduate degrees, about 500 or 600 a year, from all over the U.S. military,... |
| 00:05:532 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And what do they get when they`re there? |
| 00:05:552 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
They get a master`s in national security studies. |
| 00:05:574 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And then you mention the Center for Naval Analysis. Where is that? |
| 00:06:016 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
That`s in Alexandria, Virginia. That`s where I started when I got out of Harvard with a Ph.D back in 1990, at the end of the cold war. |
| 00:06:072 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
How many people are in that organization? |
| 00:06:0912 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
That is a federally funded research development center. It`s like the Rand Corporation. It basically works for the Department of Navy, although it has... |
| 00:06:212 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And most people in there have what, Ph.D.? |
| 00:06:2310 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
A lot of them do. And a lot of them do what they call operations research, kind of -- they`re scientists. I was sort of an odd duck there, in that I... |
| 00:06:336 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What`s the Center -- no, the Institute for Public Research? Is that a (UNINTELLIGIBLE) |
| 00:06:392 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
That`s a division within the CNA Corporation. |
| 00:06:417 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Is there, by the way, a Center for Army Analysis or a Center for Marine Analysis or a Center for Air Force Analysis? |
| 00:06:4824 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Yes, there are those kinds of -- those kinds of federally funded research and development centers and there are private corporations that do that kind... |
| 00:07:123 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
At one point in your book, you say you wanted to be a Paul Nitze. |
| 00:07:152 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Right. |
| 00:07:171 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What does that mean? |
| 00:07:1834 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, I mean, what was frustrating for me, going through and getting a Ph.D. in political science in the 1980s was that all the rules with regard to... |
| 00:07:5229 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
And so it was fairly -- it was fairly stolid. It didn`t change too much. You could master the field by memorizing, you know, a pretty small list of... |
| 00:08:212 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
You live where now? |
| 00:08:2310 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
I live with my family in Portsmouth, Rhode Island, actually on the island where the Naval War College is located. It`s the original Rhode Island in... |
| 00:08:333 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And other than writing this book, what do you do for a living? |
| 00:08:3616 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, what I do for a living is I`m a senior strategic researcher at the War College. I conduct workshops. I conduct research. I write reports. We have... |
| 00:08:524 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What is strategic planning? In other words, what other kind of planning is there? |
| 00:08:5636 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, strategic planning, which the military engages in, in a way that`s different from, I would argue, the private sector, is that they engage in truly... |
| 00:09:3224 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
And that`s fascinating. It`s challenging. But when you think about it, what the Pentagon really does primarily, as opposed to the commands around the... |
| 00:09:5624 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
So to tie it to something current today, the debate about the 9/11 intelligence failure -- I`ll tell you about it, and I write it in the book, in my... |
| 00:10:2031 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Why that doesn`t penetrate up the ranks in the Pentagon is that the Pentagon decided in the mid-1990s, when they got far enough away from the old Soviet... |
| 00:10:5131 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
We run a lot of so-called secret war games, where the unclassified description is, A large unnamed Asian land power with an unhealthy interest in a... |
| 00:11:2221 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
So when the Pentagon is focused on that definition of future war and is building for that and only wants to hear intelligence that supports that, people... |
| 00:11:433 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Let me ask you about the most political statements you make in your book. |
| 00:11:461 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
OK. |
| 00:11:473 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
At one point, your wife is afraid you`re becoming a Republican. |
| 00:11:501 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Right. |
| 00:11:512 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What does that mean? Are you not a Republican? |
| 00:11:5328 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, I`m a registered Democrat. I tend to vote Democrat. It`s an odd thing to be a Democrat who works with the military, which is overwhelming Republican.... |
| 00:12:211 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
In Wisconsin. |
| 00:12:2224 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
In Wisconsin, for the Senate. And so that`s the kind of background I come from. I will tell you, though, I tend to describe myself more like a Tony... |
| 00:12:461 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And that was when you were the... |
| 00:12:475 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Assistant for strategic futures in the Office of Force Transformation. |
| 00:12:522 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
In the Office of Force Transformation. |
| 00:12:541 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Right. |
| 00:12:552 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Is there any easier way of saying force transformation? |
| 00:12:5721 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
No. I mean, that`s one of those Pentagon buzz terms. What it means is this is the office that imagines the changing nature of war and is trying to get... |
| 00:13:182 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Who did you answer to? Who were your assistants? |
| 00:13:201 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Art Zabrowsky. |
| 00:13:211 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And what was his title? |
| 00:13:224 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
He is the director of the Office of Force Transformation in the office of the secretary of defense. |
| 00:13:261 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And who does he answer to? |
| 00:13:272 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Don Rumsfeld, secretary of defense. |
| 00:13:298 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What I`m trying to do is to simplify this to where people get, who don`t have any idea about any of this, and language and all that... |
| 00:13:371 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Right. |
| 00:13:388 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
... where they -- they can get to the point, should they go buy your book -- and what would you say to someone, who is drowning right now in language,... |
| 00:13:4627 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Right. Well, I think what you`re going to find when you read the book is it is written -- it avoids the jargon, by and large, and it is written in a... |
| 00:14:1341 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
It is interwoven with a history of my career as a strategic planner, which, in effect, takes you inside rooms that you don`t normally go inside, tells... |
| 00:14:541 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What`s a Power Point briefing? |
| 00:14:5524 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, it`s a hard thing to explain but, I mean, most people understand what a Power Point briefing is because it`s infiltrated large aspects academia... |
| 00:15:191 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What`s it look like? |
| 00:15:2027 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
It`s a series of slides that are projected behind you. And you stand up and deliver a narration to these slides. Now, the classic way you see it in... |
| 00:15:472 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
You actually say in the book you`re pretty good at this. |
| 00:15:4932 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, I will tell you, people have been telling me throughout my career that I`m one of the best Power Point briefers. And it`s a -- I will say that... |
| 00:16:2126 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, I basically do something like that, except the tableau that`s behind me is the future of warfare and I`m describing where the world is going,... |
| 00:16:478 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Let me then jump to another easily understood point. You say we should take out Kim Jong Il. |
| 00:16:5526 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, one of the arguments that I make is that if you`re going to be serious about a global war on terrorism, what you`re going to end up having to... |
| 00:17:21 |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Define that. |
| 00:17:211 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
It isn`t... |
| 00:17:221 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Define globalization. |
| 00:17:2322 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Globalization is a connectivity of communication networks. It`s a connectivity of people travel, idea movement. It`s connectivity of economic trade... |
| 00:17:4532 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
In the aftermath of the Second World War, that core that grows out, this new core of a global economy, was based on North America, Western Europe and... |
| 00:18:1713 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
So I talk about a core, a functioning core of the global economy, which is roughly two thirds of the world`s population. And then I distinguish that... |
| 00:18:30 |
Lamb, Brian - Host
The gap. |
| 00:18:302 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
The gap. What I call the non-integrating gap. |
| 00:18:328 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
I mean, before we go, you`re talking about two different things. This word comes up all the time -- core and gap. Core is two thirds of the world? |
| 00:18:40 |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Right. |
| 00:18:402 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And gap is the other third. |
| 00:18:423 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
That is poorly integrated to the global economy. |
| 00:18:451 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Name some of those. |
| 00:18:4626 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
I would run it from left to right on a map. It`s the Caribbean rim. It`s the Andes portion of South America. It`s most of Africa. It`s the Balkans.... |
| 00:19:121 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
When did the cold war end? |
| 00:19:1320 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
For me, 1990. So I`m talking about the last 14 years. Where have we gone? Because the Soviets go away and we get out of the bipolar competition with... |
| 00:19:331 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
A hundred and fifty times? |
| 00:19:344 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
A hundred and fifty times. And all I did was, I drew a line around that -- that figure. |
| 00:19:382 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
(CROSSTALK) |
| 00:19:401 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And you have that map in the book. |
| 00:19:4118 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Right. And I say, What unifies these regions? And what I find is these regions uniformly are less connected to the global economy than that functioning... |
| 00:19:591 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
They`re not always democracies, though. |
| 00:20:0016 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
No, not always democracies. But what I talk about in the functioning core is that you`re -- what I see in these countries are that they`re consistently... |
| 00:20:164 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
I`ve got to stop you again because you use this a lot -- rules set. |
| 00:20:201 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Rule sets. |
| 00:20:212 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Sets, S-E-T-S. |
| 00:20:231 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Right. |
| 00:20:243 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Rules -- is it rule sets? |
| 00:20:27 |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Rule sets. |
| 00:20:271 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
OK, rule sets. |
| 00:20:281 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Rule sets. |
| 00:20:291 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Yes. And you use that all the time. |
| 00:20:303 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Right. |
| 00:20:33 |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What is a rule set? |
| 00:20:3320 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, as I explain at the beginning of the book, one way to think about a rule set is it`s the way the game is played. It`s the rules of the game, OK?... |
| 00:20:539 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And you say it`s changed in 1776 and in -- jumping ahead to 1861, or all the years, it seems like, when war happened. |
| 00:21:0232 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Yes. Because usually, what war represents is that the rule sets have gotten so dangerously out of whack that there is such either anger or dissatisfaction... |
| 00:21:3447 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Here`s an example. You get connectivity in the Internet, and you have new definitions of dangers, like stalking on the Internet. And until you create... |
| 00:22:211 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Go back to Kim Jung Il. |
| 00:22:221 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
OK. |
| 00:22:231 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Take him out. |
| 00:22:2434 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, here`s that argument about disconnectedness defines danger. So I look at the world and I say, Show me the places that are poorly connected, I`ll... |
| 00:22:5847 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
So I look at a Saddam Hussein. I look at a Kim Jong Il. Kim Jong Il in North Korea is one of the most disconnected societies in the world. Three million... |
| 00:23:4538 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
So when I see a Kim Jong Il and I see that kind of disconnectedness, I say, by definition, this is a bad guy. And I will argue, if you want to make... |
| 00:24:235 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
By the way, back to your Power Point briefings. How many times have you given one? |
| 00:24:283 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
I`ve given probably a thousand or more. |
| 00:24:312 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
How many people usually in the audience? |
| 00:24:3315 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Anywhere from -- I do -- sometimes -- I`ve done ones for senior leaders, where it`s the one guy in the room, and I`ve done them for as many as 500 or... |
| 00:24:485 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And how many other people are there in this town like you that give Power Point briefings? |
| 00:24:5332 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, there are a lot of people who get Power Point briefings. What I get told a lot after Power Point briefings is that they`ve never seen anything... |
| 00:25:256 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Most guys like you who give Power Point briefings don`t end up getting in "Esquire" magazine. |
| 00:25:31 |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
No. |
| 00:25:316 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And they don`t end up writing books that are on -- you know, that -- this book is -- I can`t even see -- who published this book? |
| 00:25:371 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
G.P. Putnam`s Sons. |
| 00:25:381 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Yes. So it`s a -- it`s a... |
| 00:25:392 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Serious house. |
| 00:25:412 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
... serious trade publication -- I mean, trade... |
| 00:25:431 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
A mass -- a mass book. |
| 00:25:441 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Mass books. |
| 00:25:451 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Yes. Not a trade publication, in effect. |
| 00:25:468 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Right. Well, but it`s a trade book, they call it, in the hardback nonfiction category. The question to you, though, is, how did you get this into an... |
| 00:25:5432 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, I`ll tell you, I spent most of my career across the `90s making these arguments about how national security had to come closer and understand... |
| 00:26:2631 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
But I knew that something would come down the pike that would make those connections more clear. 9/11 did that for me, OK? At that point, my description... |
| 00:26:5720 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
And so I started briefing it outside of DoD, and on that basis, I started briefing it to private sector industries, like international financial community,... |
| 00:27:1735 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
And so when I say, This is where the Pentagon and war and peace and the arguments of national security fit within, you know, the great unfolding of... |
| 00:27:5231 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
They ask around. They`re told, Hey, you got to see this guy. He`s got this brief. It`s weird as hell. He gives it all the time. He`s kind of a cult... |
| 00:28:2331 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
And so they picked me as one of their best and brightest. They put me in the December issue. At that point, "Esquire" says, We got to see this brief.... |
| 00:28:5440 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
I mean, the fear factor in the American public is, in effect, Where are we going with this? I mean, we`re going to do Afghanistan. We`re going to do... |
| 00:29:343 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What do you think, by the way, of George Bush and what he`s done so far? |
| 00:29:373 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, let me get -- let me get all the way to the book here, and then I`ll answer that question. |
| 00:29:401 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
OK. |
| 00:29:412 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Because I have a tendency to jump around, and it makes it harder for... |
| 00:29:431 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And so do I, so we`re in bad shape here, if we`re not careful! |
| 00:29:442 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
(LAUGHTER) |
| 00:29:4637 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
So I write the article for "Esquire," and it does -- you know, it`s passed around the Pentagon. It`s passed all over the world. I get foreign military... |
| 00:30:2320 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
At that point, the agents start coming after you, and they say you`ve got to take this message to the American public. And I say, you know, I`m a weird... |
| 00:30:4336 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
So I cut a deal with Mark Warren, who`s the executive editor of "Esquire," and I say, you come and be my personal editor on this book, let`s see who... |
| 00:31:198 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
So I have to explain who I am and how I came up with all of these things for it to be a sellable concept, for people to say I not only believe it, but... |
| 00:31:2721 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
So we write this book. We spent a lot of time thinking about how we`re going to make it translatable to a mass audience, and what we`re getting so far... |
| 00:31:485 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
But in the end, you actually probably reach more people through "Esquire" magazine than you do through the book sales, right? |
| 00:31:5328 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, it`s hard to say. "Esquire" is big. I mean, I hope the book will reach a large audience, and GP Putnam & Sons certainly helps. I mean, they`re... |
| 00:32:211 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
George Bush. |
| 00:32:2213 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
George Bush. You know, what I basically say in the book is, I think the way to think of him historically is much like -- not a Woodrow Wilson, certainly... |
| 00:32:3524 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
The way I look at it, George Bush is, I say he`s very much like a Harry Truman. He`s at a point much like after the second world war, where we`re confronting... |
| 00:32:5910 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
And to build something that will outlive his presidency, to create strategic concepts that other administrations, Democrat and Republican, can pursue... |
| 00:33:0917 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
I try to deliver that in this book. I mean, I sell it quite openly as a successor to the Cold War strategy of containment. Like they did back then,... |
| 00:33:262 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Do you find that what he did in Iraq was right? |
| 00:33:2819 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
I make the argument that if you want to deal with terrorism, I mean, there are like three ways you can deal with terrorism, roughly. You can put a firewall... |
| 00:33:476 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
You can try to kill terrorists as quickly as possible. But my argument would be, they`re going to grow them faster than you can kill them. |
| 00:33:5319 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
I think what you have to do is you have to deny terrorists and terrorist networks the outcomes they seek. And I would argue that the outcomes they seek,... |
| 00:34:1227 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
So bin Laden, I would argue, historically is not unlike a Lenin and the Bolsheviks a century earlier, in a different era of globalization, who said,... |
| 00:34:3910 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
And when I see that kind of disconnectedness develop between large chunks of humanity, invariably they start looking at each other as enemies. And there`s... |
| 00:34:4921 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
So when I see a bin Laden saying, in effect, I want to grab the Middle East and pull it out of the world because I think this globalizing world is going... |
| 00:35:1035 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Now, how do you tie an Iraq situation into that? The only way you`re going to deny the terrorists the outcomes they seek in the Middle East is to connect... |
| 00:35:4512 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
The only way you`re going to stop a bin Laden from trying to pull off what he`s going to try to pull off in the Middle East is to connect a Middle East... |
| 00:35:5710 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Now, to do that you have to take out those entities or those agents within that security community there, which is very insecure, I would argue, who... |
| 00:36:0728 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
And Saddam Hussein was a tremendous force of disconnectedness. He created insecurity throughout the region. He kept the Iraqi people tremendously disconnected... |
| 00:36:3539 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
So when we take down an Iraq and try to connect an Iraqi society to the outside world, we create, and I would argue what the Bush administration argues... |
| 00:37:141 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
So it was a good idea? |
| 00:37:1524 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
I think it`s a good idea. I think it`s a long term idea, and I think the way it was sold to the American public was probably not so good. And I think... |
| 00:37:3921 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
What`s an example of such a rule set? I would say we have one for economically bankrupt states. It`s called the International Monetary Fund`s sovereign... |
| 00:38:0039 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
We do not have one for processing a bad, politically bankrupt leadership that nobody wants, that everybody wants to see gone. OK? So the world wanted... |
| 00:38:3912 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
We don`t have an international organization or a rule set that says this is how we build your nation back up after we take down your leadership, and... |
| 00:38:5115 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Let me read a quote from your book, to see if you remember this quote. "Don`t those idiots in the White House realize they`re destroying the concept... |
| 00:39:0634 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
My mother said that. My mother said that after she saw the speech, the historic speech where George Bush enunciated the concept of preemptive war as... |
| 00:39:408 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
That`s a fairly stable rule set. OK? There has been no war among great powers since we invented nuclear weapons well over half a century ago. OK? |
| 00:39:4843 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
None of that changes with this new enunciation of preemptive war, because that enunciation of this new concept of preemptive war has nothing to do with... |
| 00:40:3132 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
So when Bush and this administration effectively enunciate the concept of preemptive war, what I say is, you got to understand, there are two different... |
| 00:41:032 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Is your mother still in Wisconsin? |
| 00:41:051 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Yes, she is. |
| 00:41:061 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Where? |
| 00:41:071 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
She lives in Boscobel. |
| 00:41:081 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Where is that? |
| 00:41:0915 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Small town, southwest Wisconsin. She has just published the third volume of her compendium, which examines the history of female protagonists in English... |
| 00:41:241 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What`s an Edgar? |
| 00:41:253 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
An Edgar is the award for mystery writers. |
| 00:41:281 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What does she do? |
| 00:41:2940 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
She has -- she met my dad in law school in the mid-1940s, after the second world war. My dad was in the Navy. She quit law school. Had nine children.... |
| 00:42:092 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
I take it she`s a Democrat. |
| 00:42:112 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
She is very much a Democrat. |
| 00:42:131 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And what about your father? |
| 00:42:143 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
My father just passed away about a month ago. |
| 00:42:171 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
A month ago? |
| 00:42:181 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Yes. |
| 00:42:191 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
How old was he? |
| 00:42:206 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
He was 81. He was a small-town attorney for about 45 years. He was -- he was Atticus Finch. |
| 00:42:263 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And he`s another Democrat? |
| 00:42:2918 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Yes, he was. He was a Kennedy delegate. A lot of Republicans go on further back. His dad was a staunch Republican. Always blamed my mother for turning... |
| 00:42:4724 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
And again, I tend to vote Democrat. I`m a registered Democrat. I don`t have any problem working with Republicans at all. I mean, my job as a government... |
| 00:43:111 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And your wife is a Democrat? |
| 00:43:124 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
My wife is an ACLU, card-carrying member. She`s very much a Democrat. |
| 00:43:166 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
So by -- did they get mad at you for supplying this document here that -- it reinforces what George Bush is doing. |
| 00:43:2226 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, there`s a certain amount of concern in my family that what I`m doing is helping reelect George Bush. But you know, I see that the challenge of... |
| 00:43:4823 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
So, I see a lot of good things in this administration in terms of the responses they`ve made to change the Defense Department and to change national... |
| 00:44:1115 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
And so I want to see those holes filled. I want to offer that vision to America. I think it`s a tremendously optimistic vision. If it helps explain... |
| 00:44:265 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
You tell us on a number of occasions in the book you`re a Catholic. Why is that important to know? |
| 00:44:3128 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, I think it explains the focus on rules. The Catholic Church, very much a rule-bound sort of organization. There are rules for this and rules for... |
| 00:44:5917 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
So throughout my career, I`ve been very good at getting grades or promotions and those kinds of things throughout an academic research sort of a career,... |
| 00:45:1632 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
So it`s been my outlook on rules that says, when you get to this point in history where things seemed like they`ve changed dramatically from a Cold... |
| 00:45:4812 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
So I`ve spent a career, almost a decade and a half, trying to figure out how the world works and how it makes sense to argue that America plays an important... |
| 00:46:001 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
You`re how old? |
| 00:46:011 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
I`m 41. |
| 00:46:023 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Daughter Emily got cancer. |
| 00:46:051 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
When she was 2. |
| 00:46:061 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
How old is she now? |
| 00:46:071 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
12. |
| 00:46:082 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What impact did that have on you? |
| 00:46:1018 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, it impacted me a lot in the sense that, you know, I`ve come to Washington to be a political military analyst, to be a policy wonk of any sort.... |
| 00:46:2822 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
So the career I had up until she got cancer in 1994 was a fairly caustic, typical kind of -- I wrote negative reviews of other people`s concepts. I... |
| 00:46:5029 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
When Emily has her cancer and it reorders your sense of priorities and what you want out of life. I decided at that point I was going to stop being... |
| 00:47:1914 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
And I got to a point in the work about two or three years after Emily`s cancer where I thought I can`t do anymore within the DOD community to understand... |
| 00:47:3346 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
And what the War College offered up in Newport was this unique research partnership with Cantor Fitzgerald, the bond trader firm, where they had asked... |
| 00:48:195 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Go back to the Cantor Fitzgerald. How many died in the World Trade Center? |
| 00:48:246 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, from Cantor Fitzgerald, I think it was upwards of -- somewhere between 650 and 700. About two-thirds of the people. |
| 00:48:302 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Did you know any of them? |
| 00:48:3230 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
I knew quite a few of them. I mean, we did a series of workshops there. All of them were at World Trade -- World Trade Center 1, on the 107th floor,... |
| 00:49:0217 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
And you know -- I was -- it was stunning to have all that tremendous loss of life. I don`t pretend to have anywhere near the loss of the people who... |
| 00:49:198 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
How many days had you been -- before you had been in the World Trade Center on September the 11th? |
|
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Been there two or three dozen times. | |
| 00:49:273 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
But I mean, how soon before that happened had you been there? |
| 00:49:3022 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, we met with some senior Cantor people about four days before the attacks, and I was set to meet -- I was going to be there probably on a Tuesday... |
| 00:49:525 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
But again, September 11 situation is a need for a new rule set? |
| 00:49:5722 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Yeah. I mean, Emily`s cancer was sort of a need for a new rule set in my family. It reordered my life, my definition of what was good and worthy in... |
| 00:50:192 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Have we got them yet? |
| 00:50:2123 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, I mean, you fly on a plane, do you think we have some new rules in terms of how you fly on a plane? Yes, there has been quite a few rules there.... |
| 00:50:446 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
The Patriot Act is a new rule set, which scares some people and makes other people feel more secure. |
| 00:50:5039 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
The preemptive war concept is a new rule set. So we have created a ton of new rules since 9/11, and, you know, all those new rules are frightening to... |
| 00:51:2916 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
In your book, talking about -- you have got a big book here talking about the Pentagon map and the future and rule sets. But on page 365, you start... |
| 00:51:451 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Absolutely. |
| 00:51:4618 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And you say: "I simply cannot watch most of these shows for more than a minute or two without sensing that my strategic IQ is dropping with each idiotic... |
| 00:52:041 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Right. |
| 00:52:0514 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
... because questions are what keeps you from tuning in, but the cumulative result of this flood of unanswered answers is a public that often feels... |
| 00:52:1947 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
I think it is in many ways. I mean, a venue like this, where I can talk about a book for 25, 30, 45 minutes, or get a chance to do that on talk radio,... |
| 00:53:0618 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
And the public needs that kind of reporting to a certain extent, but with 24-hour broadcast news networks, we also need to see a lot more discussion... |
| 00:53:243 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
You get inside the Pentagon, when you brief, and inside corporations when you brief, and have you ever briefed the Congress? |
| 00:53:27 |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
I have. I briefed Mac Thornberry`s group on the Hill. |
| 00:53:271 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Do they sit... |
| 00:53:282 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
And I briefed the House of Commons over in England. |
| 00:53:301 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Do they sit still long enough to hear the point? |
| 00:53:31 |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Absolutely. Absolutely. |
| 00:53:3110 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Would you say to the public, if they saw what goes on inside the Pentagon, with these hundreds of people devoted to analysis and strategic planning,... |
| 00:53:4147 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
They are. They`re thinking very strategically. But you know what? The material that`s developed there that drives a lot of these decisions creates these... |
| 00:54:281 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
For instance, you go way out in the future, like 2025, where you say we might need an Asian NATO? |
| 00:54:2926 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Absolutely. And that`s one of the reasons why I wanted to take down a Kim Jong Il. Because I see, for example, right now, a plan within the Pentagon... |
| 00:54:552 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Good idea? |
| 00:54:578 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, they say it`s about North Korea. What anybody who looks at this picture notices automatically is China is on the other side of that line too.... |
| 00:55:054 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
General Eisenhower warned us about the military-industrial complex. |
| 00:55:092 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
And driving policy. Right. |
| 00:55:115 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
We have $450 and above billion defense budget. |
| 00:55:16 |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Right. |
| 00:55:1611 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Is it enough? |
| 00:55:277 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
I think it`s more than enough. I mean, if all you want to do is defend this country, I can defend the country for about $100 billion. If we`re spending... |
| 00:55:34 |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Good idea? |
| 00:55:348 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
I think it`s a very good idea, because I think we`re the only country that can actually pull it off. And that when we do that, we create peace and prosperity... |
| 00:55:4210 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Shouldn`t some of the others -- I didn`t mean to interrupt -- but shouldn`t some of the others pay for this? |
|
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
That`s the question I was going to make -- that was the point I was going to make. | |
| 00:55:5242 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
They do already. OK? We float $130, $140 billion in treasury bonds, first quarter of 2003. Four-fifths of that money was bought by foreigners. Guess... |
| 00:56:345 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Did you ever have people like Paul Wolfowitz or, to jump to the political side, Karl Rove call you up and say, go Tom go, we love what you`re saying? |
| 00:56:3927 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Well, I don`t -- I don`t operate at that level, and I try not to operate on that level on some level -- in most instances, because once you get up into... |
| 00:57:0615 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
I try to stay out of that Paul Wolfowitz/Karl Rove kind of level, because once you get caught up in it -- it`s -- you get politicized. And I prefer... |
| 00:57:216 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
On the cover of the book, it says Thomas P.M. Barnett. Before we close out, what does P.M. stand for? |
| 00:57:2716 sec. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
My mother named my Thomas Patrick Barnett. When I took my wife in marriage, she said if I`m taking your last name, you`re taking my last name. I said... |
| 00:57:437 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Here is the cover of the book. It`s called "The Pentagon`s New Map: War and Peace in the 21st Century." Thomas Barnett, our guest, and we thank you... |
| 00:57:501 min. |
Barnett, Thomas P. M. - Professor
Thanks for having me, sir. |